Should People go to Prison for Calling Others Nazis?

For a great many years, long before Brexit, some on the left in politics have merrily labelled those on the right (I am not talking about the far right) as “Nazis” or “fascists”. Indeed, go back a few decades and you will find examples of men who risked their lives in the fight against Nazi Germany being described as fascists because, for instance, they objected to industries being nationalised or thought tax rates should not be astronomically high.

More recently, this childish practice has spread to people of all or any political persuasion. So, for instance, those who do not admire Anna Soubry’s passionate adoration of liberally minded Brussels bureaucrats have taken to calling her a Nazi and the Speaker of the House of Commons, this very day, has assured us that Ms Soubry’s infantile critics are themselves fascists.

It goes without saying that these allegations of fascism are, not to put too fine a point on it, plain stupid. Respectable right of centre chaps are obviously not fascists. Ms Soubry. whatever one thinks of her opinions, is certainly not a Nazi. Those disagreeable thugs who screech that she is are almost definitely not themselves fascists: they are just tiresome infants who are determined to do all in their power to destroy perfectly sound arguments for demonstrating that Ms Soubry’s opinions are not well thought out (I am told her real political allegiance is to the Liberal Democrat Party, not to the National Socialist Party formerly led by Adolph Hitler).

After years of “Nazi” and “fascist” having been allegations generally only made against male democratic Conservatives, they are now made against pretty well everyone who has ever expressed a political opinion, whatever his or her sex. These terms of abuse are now, in other words, totally meaningless. You would have thought, therefore, that no one could any longer be all that put out at finding himself or herself described as being a Nazi or fascist. But that thought would be wrong. We moderate, mostly decent, Conservative men put up for decades with being labelled as Nazis and no one ever bothered to make a fuss about it, but all has now changed.

First, and I certainly agree, it is the general opinion of MPs that it is evil to hurl common abuse at women. It continues to be the duty of men, unless they be cads and bounders, to defend women against the sort of taunts thrown around by protesters on College Green when female politicians venture there in order to give us their opinions on the issues of the day. We must get that out of the way. No decent well-brought up man could possibly think it is ever appropriate for women politicians to be criticised in intemperate terms. Horsewhipping on the steps of the offender’s club is the solution. But I doubt criminal prosecution would really be appropriate.

This is where, I regret, I have to become controversial. Ms Soubry has said that it is the duty of the police to prosecute the tiresome protesters who called her a Nazi. I must be careful here. It is a great many years since I practised in the criminal courts. And I am aware that Ms Soubry, a barrister who specialises in criminal law, is much more up to date than I am. She is also, of course, a member of the House of Commons and will, as a result, have witnessed at first hand the passing of many barmy laws designed to consign lots of hitherto innocent people to prison. As Auberon Waugh so accurately put it, the British are punishment freaks, and their MPs are the most extreme punishment freaks of all. I certainly wouldn’t put it past them to have made a law requiring the courts to imprison anyone who ever called a slightly left-wing female politician a Nazi.

But, with all those caveats, I have to say that my researches suggest that it is not yet a criminal offence to call a politician (or anyone else) a Nazi or a fascist. So the question arises: should the law be changed so as to provide that anyone who calls Ms Soubry, or any other vaguely left-wing female politician, a Nazi must be sent to prison? I put it as narrowly as that because I recognise that Ms Soubry would not wish it to be a criminal offence to call a politician who advocates our departure from the EU a Nazi. That would lead to lots of her pals (“Lord” Adonis springs to mind) being banged up (and John Bercow would definitely be at risk). And, anyway, she would not wish the criminal law to be too widely drawn. It should deal with what we lawyers call “the mischief”, and not go beyond that. The mischief here is that a slightly left-wing female politician has been called a Nazi: that, she would say, must never happen again.

I do understand Ms Soubry’s concern. She has not had to put up with idiots calling her a Nazi for anywhere as long as I have had to cope with the same insult being thrown at me. It must have been a thoroughly beastly shock for her. And I can assure her that my horsewhip is ready should I ever come across any of her tormentors on the steps of his club. But, though I hate to disappoint her, I have to say that I honestly think that making it a criminal offence to call Ms Soubry a Nazi would be a step too far.

Charles

9 thoughts on “Should People go to Prison for Calling Others Nazis?

  1. Making it a criminal offense to call her a Nazi would open up a new world of ctiminal law, surely?
    What about fascist, prostitute, bitch, slag, liar, cheat, woman? Where would one draw the line?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Well said Charles, albeit somewhat lengthily.
    I strongly suspect that the vast majority of people could not define ‘Nazi’ or ‘Fascist’. These words have become so excessively used and abused, as to become meaningless. The advent of ‘Hate Crimes blah, blah’ is an unfortunate and rather ignorant further descent by our once respected legal system.
    BTW, the revelation that Soubry is a barrister, lends even more weight to my point.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It’s a sign of the times, Addy, and not only with the Nazi term.
      Say we have too much immigration and you are a racist.
      Say she’s a beautiful woman and you are a misogynist or sexist.
      Say that you find homosexuality a little odd, and you are a homophobe.
      Labels are the 21st century’s tool for twats… Oops, I used a label.

      Liked by 2 people

    • What do you mean by ‘extreme right wingers’? Anyone to the right of the now moved to centre-left Conservative Party? Anyone who wants this country not to be ruled by Brussels? Anyone who thinks mass immigration is not making the UK a nicer place to live?

      Like

Add your comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s