Will it be the Conservative Manifesto or Mrs May’s Manifesto?

One day next week the Conservative Party’s manifesto will be published. But it will have been written with no input from any member of the Conservative Parliamentary Party other than the Prime Minister. No cabinet minister, it seems has been consulted. All has been left to one of Mrs May’s unelected special advisers, a Mr Nicholas Timothy.

I can’t help thinking that this a very bad idea. I have nothing personally against Mr Timothy. I have never even met him. I know he is a great admirer of Joseph Chamberlain, and there is something to be said for old Joe (though I would be happier if Mr Timothy’s admiration were directed to Edmund Burke). My concern is that Mrs May is said to be intending to land her party with a manifesto which will be widely disliked by her colleagues in the House of Commons.

There has always been tension between authoritarians and libertarians in the Conservative Party. On the whole, though, the libertarians have been in the ascendancy since Mrs Thatcher became leader. The rhetoric, even if not the practice, of Tories has been in favour of the individual and against big government. I think it reasonable to assume that most Tory MPs (or at least those who are capable of thought) retain, to this day, an affection for liberty and a dislike of big government.

But all the signs are that Mr Timothy and Mrs May are determined to saddle their party with a manifesto which will attack liberty and promote big government.

Mrs May, unlike Mrs Thatcher, came to power without ever revealing any political opinion. Nothing wrong with that. Ideologies are not all they are cracked up to be. But all those MPs who voted for her must, I suspect, have assumed she was broadly “on side”. Perhaps that was foolish of them. After all, Mrs May had been Home Secretary for far longer than could possibly be healthy. There must have been at least a possibility that all those years in the Home Office would have led her to “go native”, to accept the traditional Home Office view that the man in Whitehall knows best how we should all live our lives.

Mr Timothy was Mrs May’s special adviser for most of her time as Home Secretary. His adoration of Joseph Chamberlain will have predisposed him to a dislike of liberty (ironic that a so-called Liberal became such an opponent of free trade). Mixing, every day, with all those Home Office civil servants (every one of them champions of authoritarianism over libertarianism) was bound to lead to his favouring big government.

The result of all this, so we are told, is that the Conservative manifesto is going to promise us higher taxes, much more red tape, endless government interference in commerce and industry and a general approval of authority over liberty (the European Union under a different name).

Many of my delightful readers will see nothing wrong with that. But my point is that most true Conservatives will disagree with them. What is more, it is obvious nonsense for the Tories to think they can attract traditional Labour voters by claiming to support traditional Labour policies. Yes, many Labour supporters will vote for Mrs May, but not because she says she wants higher taxes and more government interference in their lives. They are going to support her, this time round, because she says she will deliver Brexit and she is not Jeremy Corbyn.

I think Mrs May would have been wiser to give Mr Timothy a break and let her cabinet colleagues write her manifesto.

Charles

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Will it be the Conservative Manifesto or Mrs May’s Manifesto?

  1. Perhaps it doesn’t matter much how a political party manifests itself if it wins them power Charles. A group of Conservatives found themselves with a court ruling that said a Political Manifesto has no legal force. And as Sir Keith Joseph said (of what he called the socialist ratchet), ‘The Tories loosened the corset of socialism; they never removed it’.

    Like

  2. I have never trusted her since I sensed the authortarian in her, around her third year as Home Secretary. Perhaps I am a bit slow on the uptake but better late than never. Not that my opinion will make a blind bit of difference.

    Like

  3. The Tory manifesto can’t possibly as bad as Labours, they really want to take us back to the year dot. Let’s give Mrs May a fair crack of the whip, she is not my favourite person, I think we expect too much, it’s only two months since the other 27 members were informed that we are really leaving, I am referring to article 50.

    Like

Add your comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s