Are we all Punishment Freaks?

I think it was the late (and very great) Auberon Waugh who coined the expression “punishment freaks” to describe the perceived love of the British (he actually said it was more of an English thing than a UK one) for the imposition of harsh punishments for people of whom they disapproved.

But I wonder whether he was right. Of course, no can dispute this, most MPs, of all parties (this is not a party political piece), are definitely punishment freaks. They disagree as to whom they wish to imprison, but they agree that prison is a jolly good thing and should be used for many more people than it is at present. Give a backbench MP the opportunity of introducing a private member’s billĀ  and he or she will almost certainly dream up a new imprisonable offence. What is the point of being an MP, they ask themselves, if one can’t arrange for people of whom one disapproves to be sent to prison?

And yet I doubt whether there is an overwhelming longing, amongst those MPs’ constituents, for more and more people to be sent to prison for longer and longer. Of course, there is almost universal agreement that dangerous violent offenders should be locked up for as long as possible. But I suspect it is only MPs and magistrates, for instance, who think it excellent fun to send people to prison for not buying television licences or failing to pay the Council Tax. And then there are those cases, we read of them often, where defendants are sent to prison for non-violent offences committed as a result of desperation or illness. We ask ourselves: “why did the judge do that?” The answer, in almost every case, is that the judge assumes that politicians’ adoration of prison for inadequate people is a reflection of the British public’s opinion.

Whatever the reasons, we now have almost the highest per capita prison population in the free world. America beats us, but practically no other country does. The cost to the taxpayer is gigantic. The imprisoned people do not reform (they can’t get jobs or homes when they emerge from behind bars). No one tries to help them sort their lives out. They just come back for more.

This is all desperately distressing, and I am convinced that most of my decent compatriots agree. The MPs, however, do not. They, either because they are genuine punishment freaks who get a buzz from thinking of people being incarcerated or, one must be charitable, because they think there are votes in state brutality, can see nothing wrong with our policy of sending as many people to prison as possible.

For a while, it looked as though reform might be on the way. We went through a horrid period when Chris Grayling was “Justice” Secretary. For him, it was all about votes. He assumed the voters wanted brutality, and he assured them he would give it to them. But then we got Michael Gove. Now, I do know that he is very unpopular for having been on the winning side in the EU referendum. But he was an amazingly enlightened and intelligent Justice (we can do without the quotation marks in his case) Secretary. He was determined to do something about the scandal of our horribly high prison population. And he was also just as determined to do something serious about rehabilitation of offenders. But the Prime Minister does not like him. She got rid of him and appointed, in his place, an MP in the Grayling mould called Liz Truss.

Ms Truss, assuming there are votes in this, has now told us that she wants our prison population to continue to be higher than that of the vast majority of free countries. She adopts the now normal tactic of politicians of misleading us. She says all those prisoners are nasty, violent offenders. The fact that most of them are not, does not trouble her conscience. “Justice” Secretaries are there to get votes, not to advance justice.

I can forgive Mrs May a lot, but I am sure she did us an enormous disservice by allowing her personal dislike of Michael Gove to deprive us of a first rate Justice Secretary.



9 thoughts on “Are we all Punishment Freaks?

  1. Charles, Just today I was thinking about something very similar going on here in the U.S. Of course it’s the Liberal loser nutters who are determined to punish every soul who dares support our new president or oppose their agenda. My thoughts turned to Aleppo, Syria and the two opposing sides killing each other. We are not there yet thank goodness.


      • Those of a liberal disposition only see the collective, they do not see the individual. Therein lies great danger.

        Stalin was right for once when he said something to the effect that a single death was a tragedy but a million simply a statistic.


  2. I agree with your sentiments to some degree Charles, but I do like to think that bad eggs are banged up. I don’t suppose there were many TV licence offenders in that Northern prison having the riots.
    Which brings me to my point. Surely, prisons could be graded as to the severity of the crimes commited by the inmates. Similarly, the opprobrium attached to an ex-prisoner could be graded accordingly. After all, who could object to someone who had the guts to stand up to the ghastly BBC.
    What I would like to see, is a demographic of prison populations – something never to be revealed due to the standard PC ‘principles’. As with hospitals and schools, I suspect that prisons have been adversely affected by the immigration cloud burst.
    Finally Charles, I was pleased that you bravely touched upon the ‘wisdom’ of judges these days. It seems that every day there is a report of a bizarre sentence being given for a relatively mild offence, or alternatively, some dreadful creature has been effectively let off. I’m definitely against reducing prison populations, simply to gladden the hearts of the liberal clique. After all, it’s quite easy to avoid going to prison.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I never understood what was gained by sending Jeffrey Archer to prison. Charles will correct me, but I concluded it happened because he was unpopular.


Add your comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s